About Sounding Off

Ted Robinson of NBCSports.com fires away on what’s making news in Major League Baseball, the National Football League and professional tennis.

Robinson called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has done play-by-play for the Minnesota Twins, San Francisco Giants, and New York Mets. Since 2000 Robinson has provided play-by-play for NBC Sports on the French Open and Wimbledon. He also previously served in that role at the U.S. Open for USA Network. Robinson is also the play-by-play voice of the San Francisco 49ers on KNBR.



Federer no lock in French final

Posted: Friday, June 05, 2009 5:18 PM

 

The French Open has been filled with high drama, and the final act, Sunday’s men’s singles final, could be the culmination of great tennis theater. Roger Federer seeks to complete a career Grand Slam, and in doing so match Pete Sampras’ record for most majors won (14). Robin Soderling, the No. 23 seed and not even on the radar when this major began, seeks to cap his improbable Roland Garros run with a title.

 

Federer has never played in a major like this, contesting every game rather than dominating. Rather than hovering above the field, allowing no mortal to challenge, he has been engaged in fierce battles, four times playing from behind to overcome opponents, the best of these efforts coming against Juan Martin del Potro 3-6, 7-6 (2), 2-6, 6-1, 6-4 in the semifinals.

 

The Swiss’ track record this fortnight in Paris makes a prediction for the final difficult. Federer has reached a fourth straight Roland Garros title match, having lost the last three to Rafael Nadal. But it is not Nadal who is awaiting him this time around, but rather Soderling, who is on a career-best run. Federer is hardly performing at his best, yet he plays on Sunday in his 15th final in the last 16 Grand Slam events. Incredibly, he’s also made it to 20 straight semifinals at the majors. We will never again see the likes of such excellence.

 

Federer’s return game is still a notch below what it was in the past. It’s well above average without a doubt, but too often opponents are coasting through sets without a push from Federer. And that could be a problem on Sunday. No doubt that Federer handles the moment, his two comeback five-set wins show that he can handle the pressure that grew out of Nadal’s early exit. But he will face a man playing superior tennis, the best tennis of his career.

 

Against Fernando Gonzalez in the semifinals, for two sets Soderling continued the brilliance that got him past Nadal and Nikolay Davydenko. Soderling was playing power clay-court tennis, handling high balls with astounding strength, and hammering wide flat serves to great effect. In essence, Soderling, on the red clay, has forced his opponents out of their game.

Just when Soderling appeared poised to knock out Gonzalez, the Chilean found his serve, and stayed on court long enough to allow Soderling’s level to slip. It was the first sign of weakness shown by the Swede in his last four matches, and the dip allowed Gonzalez to reach the fifth set with a 4-1 lead.

And then from somewhere Soderling found one more push. Inspired by the front-row presence of fellow Swede Bjorn Borg, Soderling played well enough to cut his deficit to 4-2. He pumped a fist at Borg, and proceeded to regain the physical edge. Four more games and Soderling was in his first Grand Slam event final.

SUNDAY’S KEYS:

FATIGUE: Does Soderling have the conditioning to rebound from his long battles with Nadal and Gonzalez as well as David Ferrer in the third round? Federer has also played long matches, but his fitness is unquestioned, and he is accustomed to the two-week grind of a major. Until this fortnight, Soderling had not gotten past the third round of a major.

STAGE FRIGHT: Watch Soderling’s feet in the first set. Nerves often are exposed by footwork. Soderling has moved beautifully at Roland Garros. If he continues to show that in the first set on Sunday, he will have conquered his nerves.

POWER: Can Federer withstand Soderling’s punishing attack? Fair question, it seems, since Nadal used a similar game to take Federer out three years running.

DESTINY: The French Open is the only major Federer has never won. Is the Swiss Master ready for his best chance to win Roland Garros, and earn recognition as the greatest player of all-time?

 

Is Soderling, who has come out of nowhere in Paris, destined to complete one of the greatest runs ever at a major, beating both Nadal and Federer to win the title?

 

Sunday will provide the answer, and either way a great story will have been written on the dirt at Roland Garros, one that will go down in French Open lore.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Can't you guys leave the tennis to ESPN so that we could watch live or replays and judge for ourselves, rather than wait for your tiny snippets that comes 24 hours after the facts. I believe NBC should be banned from sports broadcasting. Just like in the case of the Olympic games you cherry pick what the public is "allowed" to see. That's not fair play.
I agree that Federer isn't a lock to win, but I certainly hope he does.  He really, really needs to win the first set so that he can relax and play his game.  Playing from behind puts him on the defensive and Soderling would love nothing more than to pounce on a defensive Federer.  (I also want him to win the first set for purely selfish reasons.  I want to be able to relax and enjoy the match.  I think I was on the brink of a massive heart attack watching the semifinal match.)  One more, Roger, one more!  I know you can do it.
I wonder why people keep saying that Federer "needs" this win to be considered the "greatest of all time."  The fact is that Federer, up until this point, has reached the French Open final four years in a row.  Regardless of what happens Sunday, I say he has already amassed a far greater record at the French Open than Sampras and should already be considered greater than Sampras.
Soderling is playing the best tennis of his life, but I can't help but feel like Federer is going to step it up and go into "God mode" on Sunday. Surely nobody can imagine Federer giving up this incredible opportunity. Federer's game is also a problem for Soderling. Soderling hits the ball incredibly big, but he doesn't have the greatest movement, and Federer has always been able to expose this with his all-around game.

Then you also have to factor in experience. This is Soderling's first grand slam final. It kind of reminds me of last year's US Open final with Murray. Obviously, Federer has been there a ridiculous amount of times, and I think this will play a big factor.

I think Federer takes it in straights, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Swede pushed Fed to 4 or even 5 sets.
One just gets the innate feeling that nothing or nobody can or will deny Mr. Federer's grasp onto all-time greatness on Sunday.  He is accustomed to the pressure of greatness, he wants this, the French crowd is clamoring for him to proudly and finally hold the Coupe des Mosquetaires as his own.  It appears his mental state is perfect - confident and unafraid, yet not arrogant or negative at the first sign of trouble.  The drop shots he executed against del Potro in the semis were picture-perfect, his service impeccable against Monfils in the quarters, and his gutsy inside-in forehand in the third set of his fourth round match against Haas will stick out memorably in my mind.  Soderling has been nearly flawless in his wins over Ferrer, Nadal, Davydenko, and Gonzalez, and will be a challenge.  Roger in either four or five sets to achieve the eternal admiration of tennis fans worldwide.
WHY, pray tell, did NBC not broadcast the Federer/Del Potro match today?  For that matter, why did NBC only schedule three hours for the French Open's men's semi-finals?  That was a ridiculous decision!  Wasn't there a contract to broadcast the French Open "live"?  Yet what we GOT today was 'just' the taped replay of the five-set Soderling/Gonzalez match.  Altogether, this is/was a terrible dis-service to American tennis fans!
Thanks, Ted for the spot on analysis of Soderling's seeming mastery of aggression and accuracy on clay.  Still I couldn't believe it when Gonzalez let go of his secure hold on the match in the 5th.  Although he recovered from the dubious line call, each time the Swede pushed him off the court he lost some energy & belief.  Now, I love your love of the game which comes through even though you share the limelight with Johnny Mac; BUT I CAN"T BELIEVE WHAT NBC did to me and thousands of viewers nationwide.  IT ruined my day and night when Days of Our Lives appeared instead of FED, with no explanation, not even a nod to all the devoted fans.  Don't you think we deserve some acknowledgement?  something... even if we didn't get the match as it was going on live???  How are we supposed to support a sport if the network doesn't?  Still, thanks for your nuanced insights and for letting me at least AIR my complaints.

Still reeling
I've enjoyed Ted Robinson's tennis commentary since day one. Like Dick Enberg, one gets the feeling Ted is just as nice a guy off-camera as he appears to be on-camera. Always great camaradarie with his cohorts in the booth. I've been watching tennis on TV since the early '70s (Bud Collins and Donald Dell on PBS) and Ted is right up there with the best of them.
Federer will win in straight sets.  The final will be "sleepy" as week watch Federer surgically destroy a nervous Soderling.
Go ROGER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes, I agree with Ted robinson, soderling is going to pull it off tomorrow
Federer in three or four sets.....

He has a way of neutralizing power players......just ask Andy Roddick. He is 9-0 against this Swede on steroids........

By the way, tell NBC that they disrepect the game of tennis and tennis fans when they transmit key matches in videotaped form (i.e. Nadal vs Soderling)

What a travesty!!!!!!!!!!
Roger is making a nervous (but still absolutely loyal) wreck out of me.  He takes us to the edge of the cliff, makes us nervously look over at disaster, and then brings us back with cheers and gratitude for his outstanding talent.  He IS the best.
Please NBC, give up your lame pretense of broadcasting tennis and leave it to ESPN where we can see all of the matches on the (gasp) days they were actually played! Who made you think that you know what we want to see?! Whomever made that decision on the Del Potro/Federer match for instance, must be someone who dislikes tennis and would rather watch a different sport instead. So please, broadcast the sport for which you have respect and let tennis fans watch what they want to see! I don't see football games shown in the "free samples" that tennis matches are! I can hear the uproar from here if NBC or any other channel did that!
NBC should not have rights to Grand Slams unless they are fully capable of showing matches! Days of our Lives over 10 dramatic sets of Live tennis is dissapointing!
That being said GO ROGER!!!  
My sentiments are with Federer. But my gut says Soderling is going to do something amazing tomorrow...like continue the dismantling of Rafa to Federer. Plus, it'll make a more interesting story. I'm just impressed that the guy who beat the indestructible Nadal is living in the moment and taking it for what it's worth. There is no reason for him not to destroy Federer either.
Ted,

RE: Federer's Streak

Ask Mary Carillo about Chris Evert's semifinal streak. You will be surprised. If I remember correctly, Federer's will pale in comparison.
I love watchintennis on NBC...i think Ted, John and Mary do a great job!!!!!  THANK YOU for helping my broken heart by showing last years Wimbledon!!!  BTW< I don't think that Rafa is faking a knee injury for the rest...Do yuou really think he would miss playing at Wimbledon, just because he lost at the French???????????


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):