About Sounding Off

Ted Robinson of NBCSports.com fires away on what’s making news in Major League Baseball, the National Football League and professional tennis.

Robinson called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has done play-by-play for the Minnesota Twins, San Francisco Giants, and New York Mets. Since 2000 Robinson has provided play-by-play for NBC Sports on the French Open and Wimbledon. He also previously served in that role at the U.S. Open for USA Network. Robinson is also the play-by-play voice of the San Francisco 49ers on KNBR.



Credit Brewers owner for taking action

Posted: Wednesday, September 17, 2008 9:48 AM

After 24 hours to absorb the news, I haven’t changed my view of l’affaire Brewers. It  was the owner’s move to fire manager Ned Yost.

General manager Doug Melvin’s comments, particularly those where he took the blame for the unstable bullpen and admitting he wasn't sure this was the answer, all but pointed the finger at owner Mark Attanasio.

And this is not to blame Attanasio, who has been good for the team and the city. He has spent money, both on the major league roster and in the system, which has brought the first winning seasons in 15 years to Milwaukee.

So don’t blame an owner for wanting to win before a large window slams shut.

This firing is about CC Sabathia and Ben Sheets heading to free agency; Attanasio saw the huge Barry Zito and Johan Santana contracts and knew his team couldn't afford anything similar.

This is about Prince Fielder and JJ Hardy heading to arbitration, and Attanasio knows he’s on the hook for $25 million to Jeff Suppan for the next two years and wondering how long he can pay Fielder.

This has to be about Attanasio knowing his team must not have a second empty fall; the credibility of his operation is tied to this team breaking a 26-year postseason drought.

Yost was a reserved man working for an open organization. As the Brewers increased their contact with fans, Yost remained calm and private. He wasn’t the perfect fit for the direction taken by the new Brewers.

In the end, Yost was another Willie Randolph, a good manager paying the price for an inexplicable late-season fall. Except Attanasio wasn’t going to sit back and let the Brewers crash like last year’s Mets without some involvement.

If the Brewers fell short of the postseason, it’s hard to believe Yost could have been retained. So two weeks may be all he lost and it’s hard to argue, given all the circumstances surrounding the Brewers, with the owner’s urgency to win.

Now we see if Dale Sveum can get the Brewers to hit.

FIVE MORE SWINGS:

1. FIELDER’S BAT WAS ALIVE IN CHICAGO … but Tuesday’s game ended with a magnificent duel between the slugger and Kerry Wood. With the lead run on base, Fielder fought off a handful of high fastballs and worked a full count. Then Wood dropped a paralyzing slider over the heard of the plate, freezing Fielder and dealing the Brewers another agonizing loss.

2. NO HITTING PROBLEMS FOR THE PHILLIES. Down 7-4 after six innings in Atlanta, the Phils rallied for another win to take over first place with 11 games to play. Ryan Howard homered in the eighth off lefty Mike Gonzalez to win the game. Howard has eight homers this September, 40 career homers in the money month. And Brad Lidge maintained his perfect saves record for 2008 despite walking the bases loaded in the ninth.

3. MOST MANAGERS HATE MEETINGS. Jerry Manuel had a 15-minute closed-door session before Tuesday’s game in Washington. Then Odalis Perez, a pitcher the Mets had battered last week in New York, shut them out over 7 1/3 innings. Is it Groundhog Month for the Mets?

4. THE CLOSER HUMBLED TUESDAY … was Joe Nathan. He has been quietly spectacular, with a WHIP less than 1. But after the Twins rallied from an 8-1 hole in Cleveland, they ended up in extra innings. (Grady Sizemore tied the game with an eighth-inning shot off Eddie Guardado.) Then the Twins offense stalled and Nathan coughed up his fifth homer of the season, a three-run walkoff by Victor Martinez in the 11th. Gavin Floyd’s 16th win in New York pushes the White Sox 2 ½ up on the Twins.
 
5. HOW TO USE A CLOSER. Francisco Rodriguez holds the single-season save record with 58 saves, achieved by pitching only 64 1/3 innings. He has not had one save of more than three outs and has not been used in more than three consecutive games. Another reason why Mike Sciocsia is the game’s most underrated manager.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Ned Yost had to go.  His tenure was marked by underachievement in the early years, to inexplicable collapses as of late.  Let's take a look at his tenure:

2003- Leads Brewers to their worst finish ever, an abyssmal 56-106;  2004- Marginal improvement to 68-94;2005- Only 3 games out of the wild card at all-star break, the Brewers completely collapse, playing .269 ball, and finishing out of the playoffs; 2006-  Ned Yost's undying loyalty to Derrick Turn-Blow and Geoff I could never hit left-handed pitching Jenkins costs the team at least 8 wins.  The club finishes at 81-81; 2007- The Brewers gag away two seperate 8 1/2 game leads, missing the playoffs again. The Brewers have their first non-losing season since 1992; 2008- The Brewers choke away a 6 1/2 game lead for the wild-card with a combination of inept hitting and mediocre pitching from Jeff Suppan and Manny Parra.


Ned Yost made way to many bone-headed personnel moves that cost the Brewers at least 8-10 games each  year.  However, with C.C Sabithia and Ben Sheets as good as gone at the end of this year, the pitching roataion looks fair to mediocre at best.  The Brewers will look like the current San Diego Padres next year.  Looks like the drought will continue for at least another 2-3 years  
I agree - Brewers had to try something to shake/wake something up. This 2-season window of opportunity may not return for years and years.
I agree - the Brewers had to try something to shake/wake things up. This is a 2-season window of opportunity that probably won't come again for years.
Here we have the making of a rationalization for stupidity. Mr. Robinson would argue that Managers get to much credit for the success and too much criticism for the failure of a baseball team, yet here he rationalizes that firing a Manager with less than a month to go in the season is a good thing. Perhaps the owner should have fired the play-by-play guy.
Yeh, how's Sveum doing now?

Hmm, maybe by comparison Yost wasn't so awful after all.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):