About Sounding Off

Ted Robinson of NBCSports.com fires away on what’s making news in Major League Baseball, the National Football League and professional tennis.

Robinson called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has done play-by-play for the Minnesota Twins, San Francisco Giants, and New York Mets. Since 2000 Robinson has provided play-by-play for NBC Sports on the French Open and Wimbledon. He also previously served in that role at the U.S. Open for USA Network. Robinson is also the play-by-play voice of the San Francisco 49ers on KNBR.



A free pass for Jeter but not for A-Rod

Posted: Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:56 AM

Alex Rodriguez is being publicly humbled in New York. No surprise for A-Rod as he knows the rules of Gotham: He who takes the money gets both the glory and the grief. And coming up short so often in the clutch can bring a whole lot of grief one’s way. But a double standard exists in New York and don’t think it’s not at the root of some of A-Rod’s issues.

Tuesday night the Yankees had Andy Pettitte pitching in the opener of a survival series against the Red Sox. In the third inning, Pettitte jammed Jason Bay who hit a 26-hopper/roller up the middle. Derek Jeter never touched the ball, making a very late and futile dive as it bounded past him into centerfield for a RBI single. Pettitte slammed the air in frustration.

 

Those who try to analyze defensive play and performance through stats have long exposed Jeter’s lack of range. It is not a welcome topic of conversation in New York. In Tuesday’s game recaps, A-Rod was tormented for his offensive failures. Not one word was written or spoken about Jeter’s glaring defensive weakness that set up an important inning for the Red Sox.

 

How erratic is finding pitching? Brad Ziegler is now the Oakland closer. He’s a player who rose from independent ball but has wrenched the job from top draft pick Huston Street. While across San Francisco Bay, Tim Lincecum is establishing himself as the NL’s best young arm. Baseball America’s Best Tools survey of uniformed and front office and scout personnel ranked Lincecum as the league’s second-best starter.

As the Dodgers crash through the East, there’s further proof of pitching’s unstable nature: Clayton Kershaw, their answer to Lincecum, is whacked around by Washington and then, after the game, sent back to the minors.

 

After getting nothing from the four-year deal signed by Cristian Guzman, the Nationals may relish the two-year extension they reached with the shortstop last month. Guzman hit for the cycle Thursday night and his offense has been a rare bright topic in a horrid year for Washington.

Even when Scott Boras wins, he’s not satisfied. A grievance has been filed by the super agent over the agreement reached by Pedro Alvarez, Vanderbilt star who is “advised” by Boras and the Pirates. There was a record $6 million bonus but Boras has complained that the deal was reached one hour after the deadline.

 

Pirates president Frank Connelly came out of the Commissioner’s Office where he heavily advocated restraint in teams doling out signing bonus money. Not everyone has followed the word but Boras helped the mold. Sadly for all involved, Boras is not happy, although he has not uttered one word of complaint about the player picked after Alvarez, who signed with Kansas City about a minute after Alvarez for similar money. Boras and Connelly are longtime adversaries. We might be seeing proof of that.

At the Beijing airport, I checked in for the flight home alongside the bronze medal USA baseball team. One person I sought out was Matt La Porta. If you didn’t see any of the baseball games at the Olympics, La Porta took a pitch in the neck below his left ear in a heated game with China. There had been hard slides from both teams, hit batsmen and tight pitches and it all culminated with the frightening moment for La Porta, the centerpiece of Cleveland’s trade of CC Sabathia to Milwaukee.

 

Turns out La Porta was fine. He missed the next two games but returned to homer in the bronze medal game. I asked him if there were any lingering issues and he said no. He also said he had never before been hit by a pitch anywhere near the head. La Porta offered no blame, only the time-honored baseball stance that things had gotten out of hand in the emotions of the game. While the Indians exhale, La Porta said he was heading back to finish out at Double-A with no word about a September call up.

In baseball’s Olympic farewell, South Korea stunned Cuba for gold. Ed Lynch, part of the USA contingent, told me that both the Koreans and Japanese brought a major league all-star team. And there lies the reason for baseball’s demise in the Olympic world – the best Americans – the major league stars -- don’t play. International
Olympic Committee President Jacques Rogge hinted baseball would not be back in the Games until major league players from the United States were allowed to take part. Now the ball – or in this case the baseball – is in MLB’s court. What it does with it could determine if baseball returns for the 2016 Olympics.

 

FOUR MORE SWINGS:

1. Was jolted by the realization that the final Yankees-Red Sox series at Yankee Stadium is over and it’s still August How can there not be a September farewell?

 

2. While the Mets play well enough to hold the NL East lead, a position that will be threatened on their annual long U.S. Open-driven trip (Philadelphia, Florida and Milwaukee), it is the second Carlos on the Mets, he being Carlos Delgado, who is leading them with excellent numbers since the All-Star break. The first Carlos on the team, Carlos Beltran, hasn’t been nearly as productive as Delgado since the break but his grand slam against the Marlins last night was huge.

 

3. Junior Griffey has only a handful of extra-base hits since joining the White Sox. Meanwhile, overshadowed by the breakout year of Carlos Quentin, Jermaine Dye is having another strong season and has earned the immense praise of manager Ozzie Guillen as the team’s anchor.

4. It still looks like the Cubs will be tough to beat in a short series. Rich Harden is healthy, Jeff Samardzija has added depth to a strong bullpen, Kerry Wood is back and Carlos Marmol has incredible numbers. It could be a terrific October matchup if Arizona with Brandon Webb, Dan Haren and Randy Johnson meets the Cubs with Carlos Zambrano, Ryan Dempster and Harden.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

It such a "shame" that the Yankees in the last year of "cathedral" of baseball won't even try to earn a play-off birth. They don't care enough to make the effort to catch a ball, not swing at ridiculus pitches, prtect the plate with 2 strikes,or hqw thir lackluster playing makes thier fans. the outfield will not dive for the ball not to metion wall-afobic right fielder (who never hits either)infield reation time reminds me of a bunch of stoners.At the plate they don't think and use every pitch to thier best advantage each one counts now! there hasn't been a batter that strikes fear ito the other team since Posada got hurt.(bats bare handed with confidence, owns his place on the team behind the plate or standing beside it. I'm an out of state fon of 52 years And I wish you had to put up with what I put up with everyday. The team has not had coieson all season they just don't care maybe Joe Torre and the team that played as a team wasn't such a bad idea. Please remember who played on this field before you and bring honor back to the "New York Yankees" and yourselves!         sincerley Larry KIrk
Jeter=4 WS rings. ARod= ZERO. There's nothing more to add.
Jeter has 3 gold gloves and is a lifetime .316 hitter with 4 rings and you quote one play vs. Boston. Get real will you. Arod has won nothing and cannot hit in the clutch or in October.
Looking for a reason? Jeter is a true Yankee who has always conducted himself with class and dignity...a clutch player who has stepped up in many, many big games and situations throughout his career. Have his skills eroded? Of course they have as do most non-steroid users who reach their mid-30's plus he plays hurt a lot more often than the media and fans realize. a-rod? He's a dog who is better placed on a team that is 30 games out by the 4th of July and plays in games where his inability to perform in the clutch is never tested...and let's not even get into his radioactive, headline-seeking personal life. I was praying that last season-ending's ruse with arod and boras would have been allowed to play out...we would've been better off with Joe Crede and a front-line pitcher instead of wasting the $$$$$$$$$ on arod...no misspell, by the way...that's lowercase a-r-o-d.
A-Rod is the poster boy for what is wrong with the modern athlete.  The stunt pulled by his agent last fall was inexcusable, the Baby Boss had to be an idiot for re-signing him.  I would think he is a cancer in the lockerroom besides.  The only difference between Jeter and A-rod is that when Jeter has gotten in trouble, his tax issues etc, he seems to dig himself out with some sort of finness.  Plus for as long as he is a Yankee, much like all the legends before him, it will be Jeters team.  I just can't make a case myself to pull A-rod out of his self made jams.  He is Mr. April.  
arod has not won 4 world series with the yankees
I realize it's always a case of "what have you done for me lately" but don't ever compare Jeter with ARod.  Jeter in the playoffs takes his game to a higher level.  When he retires he will have at least 4 rings and will be able to say he was one of the clutch playoff hitters and defenders (his Oakland play will go down in history while catch in the stands against Red Sox will be remembered forever in NY).  ARod has some sort of mental problem in clutch situations. This is not even an issue.  It really doesn't matter if you compete for the triple crown year in and year out while routinely grounding out, weakly, in key playoff moments. That's ARod. Derek Jeter has more hits since he game in the league than any other player and several times made serious runs for batting title.  By the time he retires he might wind up in top 3 all time hits leader.  He has a .316 lifetime average that ranks very high all time while the lowest batting average he's ever had was .297.  He has .309 playoff batting average that is a near full season's at bats and his power numbers go up in the playoffs while hiting several game winning or clutch home runs. He's batting .500 as an all-star.  Nomar was on steroids as probably ARod at some point.  Jeter on steroids would have hit 40 home runs a year.  Other fans may hate him, but it's not just a cliche' to say Derek Jeter is a winner.  It's simply the truth.  
you are an idiot to write this article, jeter has 4 world series rings and he was a key part of them winning those W.S. what has A-rod done in seatle,texas and now the yankees? fail to win in big situations, he has done that all his career. jeter has proven himself on th biggest of stages so i dont think he needs to answer ro any question of his ability even though he probably would answer any question you threw at him because he is that kind of pearson. A-rod i dont think is the same guy, he is self centered and that is why he will only win a cahmpionship if jeter is on his team. your article is a joke.
If anyone gets a free pass, it is Johnny damon.  Last week, Damon's inability to get a  failed to get a sac bunt down may have cost the Yankees two games. In both instances, the Yankees were behind in the 9th and the tying run got on board before Damon, but he could not advance the runner into scoring position.    Add to that the fact that Johnny is a sub par CFer with absolutely no arm, you have to wonder why he doesn;t shoulder his fair share of blame for the Yankees or woes.   What about Jason Giambi, who has become a completely one dimensional player, it is HR or weak pop IF pop up.  

Somewhere, along the way the Yankees management fell in love with offense and forgot that quality defense is essential to winning.   Nobody demonstrates that more than Damon and Giambi.
of course A-Rod gets grief. Why shouldn't he? If I'm the opposing team and A-Rod is coming to bat in the bottom of the ninth with bases loaded, 2 outs and the game on the line, I like my chances. Until Alex proves he can perform when the pressure is on I like my chances. Not exactly a ringing endorsement of someone who is supposed to be the best player in the game. Yeah, the best player when there's no pressure!
I don't believe the Olympics should have any paid athletes competing. Not in basketball, beach volleyball, tennis, baseball, or whatever. I don't feel this is the true meaning of the Olympics.
who cares? it's only baseball.  It's slow, predictable, and like a nagging headache, it goes on and on and on.  We are approaching the BEST time of the year for sports fans.  American football, both College and Pro are starting.  English Premier League football has alread begun.  NHL hockey starts in only weeks.  Baseball??  What's that?
When pointing fingers, you can point at Jeter...you can point at Andy...you can easily point at Jason.  But he who you point the finger at the most, Sir Alex, is simply NOT an example of a double standard over Jeter.  Jeter has DONE it.  Alex has NOT.  Period.  You don't pay someone as the best player in the game for the potential of one day being the best player.  Yes, you pay him as the top 10 - maybe top 5.  But not #1.  Because he has never reached that pinnacle.  Derek has.  You know his bar reaches that high.  With Alex, you are left with nothing more but hope that one day his bar might...might...be that highh.  Cry me a river, Alex.
How many rings does Jeter have? How many rings has A-Rod earned? Seems like a good reason to leave Jeter alone.
Derek Jeter and A-Rod.  Team sports are forgiving for players since the fault of a loss can rarely be blamed on one person.  Games of all sorts are won or lost on single plays but the heroic efforts or lack thereof from individual team players, since the opening play, effect the outcome as well.  Derek and A-Rod are Yankees, not the Yankees.  I'm a Yankee fan and I am from Kalamazoo, MI.  My friends went to school with Derek.  It might color my feelings but, A-Rod is nobody to me and I feel he is doing what he can to win too.  Players in team sports aren't hung for losses automatically.  More often then not, they show up for work.  It's the management that steers the ship that controls the outcome of the whole game.  One might reflect on the Yankees direction at the top.  Where have they been in postseason for the last decade?  What changes have occurred?  How's that Dodger coach doing that was washed up?
What about Jeters poor offense this year too?  He gets paid 21M and he's essentially league average.  Add that to his bad defense and he's far more responsible for the Yankees problems than A-Rod.  Without A-Rod the Yanks wouldn't even have a winning record.
Ted:

Your comment is typical from reporters who don't cover the Yankees on a regular basis.  I've read similar articles before and they were an inaccurate as your's.  While I agree that there is a double standard in terms of how Yankee fans treat Jeter as compared to A-Rod, however that double standard is not a bad thing necessarily.  The double standard exists because one play, Jeter, has earned his stripes by significantly contributing to 4 World Series Championships while the other player, A-Rod, has not. American society has long held different standards for different people, so why would you think sports would be any different?  I've been a Yankees fan for over 30 years and lived in NY for the past 16 years prior to my recent move to LA.  I know as much about the Yankees as anyone and can tell you that Yankee fans are tough, but very knowledgeable about the Yankees and the performance of Yankee players.  While the criticism of A-Rod is tough, I believe that it is fair because he consistenly fails to produce when the team needs him the most.  Take yesterday's game for example.  The Yankees had a 6-2 lead against the Blue Jays and through a combination of poor defensive play and horrific relief pitching, surrendered that lead and fell behind 7-6.  Well it's now the bottom of the 9th and the Yankees have a nice rally going.  Jeter leads off the inning with a single followed by a walk by Abreu (I think it was Abreu, but it may have been someone else).  So you have runners on first and second bases and NO OUTS.  A-Rod comes up to bat and works the count full, but then hits into a rally killing double play.  Talk about failing the team yet again, especially when the team can't afford anymore losses.  Why couldn't A-Rod get a single like Jeter?  Had he done so, the game would atleast been tied.  Instead, the Yankees lose a CRITICAL game and a chance to win the series.  Moreover, yesterday's double play was the 11th hit into by A-Rod in AUGUST!  A-Rod deserves all of the criticism and ridicule he gets from Yankee fans, as he has been an absolute disappointment to every Yankee fan I know and I don't think the Yankees will ever win with him on the team.  While I'm not one to believe in jinxs, A-Rod's coming to the Yankees has contributed significantly to the team's continuing downward spiral.  He doesn't deserve all of the blame of even most of it (poor starting pitching, sloppy defensive play and terrible team clutch hitting are primary culprits in the team's decline), but he was brought to the Yankees to help the team win and he has not done that (he did carry the team the first two months of the 2007 season and kept them from falling further behind the Red Sox) in the five years that he's been with the Yankees.  I wish there was some way that the Yankees could rid themselves of A-Rod, but it looks like we're stuck with him.
I agree about Jeter. He get's a free pass for his past performance during the Yankee's better years, in reality he should be catching a lot more flack than A-Rod for the Yankee's current woes. Not only with his glove, but also his bat. Jeter's salary is huge, over 21 million, he is way overpaid. Over 21 million for a guy who is not top 5 at his position offensively or defensively. A-Rod makes an even 28 million but he is a top 10 player and still the best 3rd baseman in the league, arguably the best player overall in baseball. On performance is Derek Jeter is making nearly 22 million in 2008 A-Rod should be making 40 million. Until the Yankee's learn to criticise past heroes they will never be the Yankee's they had been in year's past.

Let's not also forget Jason Giambi, a player who makes will make over 23 million in 2008 and is not half the player A-Rod is. He's barely a top 20 1st baseman.

Instead of blaming A-Rod for everything, maybe Yankee fan should be happy one guy is earning his paycheck and thank him for being the only reason to watch the Yankees and one of the few reason's they even get a sniff of being in the playoff's.
Jeter has been a clutch player in regular season and post season since 1995.  He is a home grown Yankee.  ARod is none of the above.
Maybe DJ gets a free pass because he has 4 rings with the Yankees and A-Fraud's done nothing in his 5 years with the team except cease to exist during the playoffs for the Yankees.  The other major factor why the Bronx Bombers probably won't make the playoffs for the first time in DJ's stellar career, look who the coach is!  Girardi is mediocre at best and couldn't coach my son's high school team.  Torre was hands down a players coach and way more talented than Girardi will ever be.  All in all I'd rate his 1st year of coaching with the Yankees as a D-
Thank god, someone finally recognizes, and prints how bad Jeter is.. Go A-Rod
Most yankee fans are pretty knowledgeable when it comes to their team.  Most watch all the innings of almost every game....myself included.  When the season ends, i will probaly have seen at least 150 of their games.

So when i boo A-rod and cheer jeter...their is a reason for it.  I watch all the games, and know who helps this team more.  I know the yankees.  when you think that jeter should be subjected to to the same treatment as arod, you reveal you own ignorance about this team.

Mistakes and errors are going to happen...hitting into 11 double plays in the month of august is not an error or a mistake...its a choke job!!!!

Batting .350 against the red sox from April-July is a good start, but batting .150 against them in the most critical series of the year...with the season on the line...is also a choke job!!!!!

So go ahead a cheer arod's solo homerun today, a homerun that came when the game was already over(down a bunch of runs to roy Halladay means over), i'll remember saturday afternoon....9th inning...runners on first and second...no one out...arod at the plate.  A rally killing double play that probably also ended the yankee season!!!!!

By the way...jeter was the guy standing on second in that 9th inning...he had a leadoff single!!!!

You call this page looking beyond the runs, hits and errors...i think you should keep looking!!!!!!!!!!
The A-Rod/Jeter double standard is due to Jeter being a home grown Yankee with rings and the perception that A-Rod is a mercenary.  Last autumn didn't help A-Rod's case because it was so badly handled.  The off- the-field nonsense also hurt.  A-Rod is seen in New York as a greedy, calculating phoney while Jeter is the fair-haired home grown lad who is now above criticism.  Whether this is fair or not is a matter of opinion.  Since I'm a Red Sox fan, I find it all rather amusing.
sorry to say....but you really do not understand baseball or sports...Derek Jeter is a "winning" player...much like a Bill Russell..when everythings on the line...he's there...A=Rod cannot take pressure.

With the season on the line..and given a choice of one player....Manny, Albert, Deek or A-Rod...no who would you take...the last person would be A-Rod
Sorry batting a 209 avg or less with runners in scoring position does not cut it at Yankee stadium for A Rod or anybody else. Jeters  range is not an issue as he throws himself into the stands for foul balls and hits in key situations.
I thought A-Rod should have been played at short his first year with the Yankees and it has only gotten worse. If A-Rod does not have the range anymore, surely the Yankees can find or buy someone who does. Jeter is worse than Cal who should have been moved to 1st, not 3rd years earlier. Baseball loves tradition, and marketing, but it is past time for a change at SS by the Yankees.
I love my fellow Yankees fans!! They are so right. This article is stupid and pointless. The answer is pretty obvious and A-rod is such a disappointment. Jeter has proven himself time and time again in the clutch and in many other circumstances and now your gonna nitpick one lousy play he made?? get real.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):