ABOUT AT BAT

MSNBC.com baseball analyst Ted Robinson gives his take on the hits and misses by players, managers, umpires and owners in Major League Baseball.

Robinson has an extensive background in covering the sport. He called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has been the lead play-by-play announcer for the Minnesota Twins, the television and radio play-by-play voice of the San Francisco Giants, and a member of the New York Mets broadcast team.



Manny paved his way out of Boston

Posted: Sunday, August 03, 2008 8:52 AM

After seven and a half years of nonsense from Manny Ramirez, the Red Sox finally had enough. Now that the shock of the trade has passed, here are some reflections on Boston management's making the move now, and why:

 

MANNY LOST HIS OWN CLUBHOUSE: There was a despicable incident a month ago in which Ramirez attacked the team’s traveling secretary over a last-minute ticket request. On most teams, the traveling secretary is the player’s best friend, attending to their every need as a “valet.” When a traveling secretary says no to a request from a player, there is usually a valid reason. The Red Sox players apparently hold their traveling secretary in high regard, thus Ramirez’s actions lost him respect with his peers.

 

WORK STOPPAGE/SLOWDOWN: Ramirez bailed on two games, one against the Yankees, with a bad knee. The Red Sox called his bluff, very publicly, and Ramirez had to get back in the lineup. The stoppage became a slowdown when he blatantly failed to run out a ground ball against the Angels. Boston reports indicate that Red Sox general manager Theo Epstein was told by veteran players that Rodriguez’s Ramirez's time in Boston was up.

 

THE RED SOX BADLY WANTED TO MAKE THIS DEAL: They traded their cleanup hitter, a future Hall of Famer, and two young prospects for a good player, Jason Bay, who never has tasted a pennant race. And the Red Sox are paying the rest of Ramirez’s salary.

THERE’S ALWAYS SCOTT BORAS: Boras now represents Ramirez, and the agent negotiated away his client’s 10-5 rights to block a trade. Club options at the end of the deal were removed, and Ramirez will be a free agent in November. Of course, Boras reaps the immediate windfall from any deal he cuts this winter. It will be interesting to see if Manny gets a $20 million per year deal on the open market.

 

YET ANOTHER AGENT ENTERS THE PICTURE: The man who negotiated Ramirez’s Red Sox deal, Jeff Moorad, now runs the Diamondbacks, the team Ramirez will try to beat head-to-head in a pennant race.

 

HOW DO THE DODGERS DO THIS? They have acquired two players, Manny and Casey Blake, without playing one cent of salary. Yes, the Dodgers gave up prospects, but none that hurt their immediate chances. Andy LaRoche was showcased over the last two weeks as the Dodgers searched for help. The early-season play of Blake DeWitt allowed the Dodgers to feel LaRoche was expendable.

Now Joe Torre’s challenge is fitting five outfielders into three spots (Ramirez, Juan Pierre, Matt Kemp, Andre Ethier and Andruw Jones) – or more accurately four into two as Ramirez must play. Torre must sit Jones, although the Dodgers are on the hook with him for $18 million next season. 

 

PIRATES MAKE PROGRESS: They have made progress on the big-league level, although it might be hard to sustain in the final months without Bay and Xavier Nady. New general manager Neal Huntington has proven willing to deal. Now the question ,is how good are his team’s evaluations of the young prospects it acquired from the Yankees, Red Sox and Dodgers.

 

RED SOX DECIDED THEY HAD ENOUGH: They could no longer endure the daily melodrama of Ramirez and the players as verbalized by Curt Schilling. They could no longer play with someone who didn’t want to be there. It all reeks of the Nomar Garciaparra affair in 2004, and after parting ways with Garciaparra, the Red Sox won the World Series.

 

FIVE MORE SWINGS:

1. DEADLINE DEALS AREN’T WHAT THEY USED TO BE. More general managers are waiting to the winter to expand the pool of teams with whom they can trade. It was the approach taken by Minnesota in the Johan Santana derby and might explain why so few deals happened at the deadline. A surprise was that no deals for relievers -- smaller though they may be -- were struck.

2. TEAMS THAT SURPRISED WITH INACTION: How do the Cardinals expect to keep pace with the Cubs and Brewers without importing help? Or has St. Louis targeted the wild card as its best chance? And the Twins had their season ripped apart last July when veterans complained about adding no one at the deadline. The team chemistry -- always a strength in Minnesota -- suffered. No move again this season, despite the need at third base and an injury to second baseman Alexi Casilla, and no moves even though Francisco Liriano is on his way back to the Twins’ rotation.

3. KUDOS TO THE YANKEES: It was a great week in the Bronx. The Yankees added Xavier Nady, Damaso Marte and Ivan Rodriguez to help, then watched Ramirez leave the Red Sox. And let’s remember the Yankees are a threat even with their getting nothing from Jorge Posada this year, Chien-Ming Wang being injured since May and Hideki Matsui hobbled in the last month.

4. WHY DIDN’T THEY DUMP? Washington is a disaster. At the big-league level the Nationals are a mess while they rebuild a farm system decimated by the franchise having been owned for four years by Major League Baseball.
Other than Jon Rauch, the Nationals had to move bodies and bring in any available prospects.

 

Seattle is a surprise -- as bad as its season has been, a moving van to Safeco Field would have been expected. Instead, the Mariners stare at the truth that they are a distant fourth in the AL West, given the young talent imported by Texas and Oakland in the last year.

5. I’M WONDERING ABOUT THE FALLOUT IN FLORIDA over the failed attempt to trade for Manny Ramirez. The Marlins were so close to a deal but reports are they held out for too much (in surrendering prospects) and the Red Sox pulled out. Was this a play to cement a new stadium? Florida’s ownership never has shown any inclination to spend that kind of money. Was this a cruel tease to the fans? Wait, there aren’t many of those. Sentiments that I read indicate many believe the Fish were sincere in their efforts to land Ramirez. Meanwhile, on the field, Anibal Sanchez pitched for the first time in 15 months and the Marlins started August in a three-way tie with the Mets and Phillies.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Too much about Manny.  Talk about someone else.  Most of us don't care.  Spend more time on other people and teams somewhere other than the east coast.
There is another side to the Manny story.  His former agent, Jeff Moorad, or his firm, have been cheated out of their commission (of the options) by Manny's actions to get the Red Sox to drop the club options for 2009 and 2010.  Could it be said that Boston would have picked up the options had Manny honored the terms of his contract and played like he was capable?  I think so.  If I was in Moorad's position, or the firm's position, I would think hard about filing a lawsuit against Manny and Boras.  I am surprised that Bud Selig, did not intervene in this situation with his "best interests of the game" powers.  For all of Manny's acts of stupidity, and assault of a 64 year old man, he should have been suspended for the year and fined the remainder of his contract for 2007.  The traveling secretary should have filed a lawsuit.  Maybe that would have got his attention.  His grade school tantrums and subsequent actions have affected many people, all out of self interest and greed. What I would like to see is that Manny not be offered any contract at all for 2009.  It won't happen, but that is what he deserves.....to be out of the game.  Yes, I am a long time Yankee fan, however, I do not wish to see Bonds either.
mmmm, his name is Ramirez, not Rodriguez
This article does not deserve a comment.
Manny to the Dodgers. I'll bet he and Jeff Kent become the best of buddies.
I hope Kent raises a knot on Manny's Lazy Elm Head.  Talent he has; an appreciation he is the custodian of that gift...he hasn't got a clue.  After baseball Manny better get a new phrase down, "Will there be fries with that order sir?"  A gifted athlete with no class as a public figure.
cut your hair and play baseball
As a Manny appologist, management supposedly promised manny his contract would be discussed as he expressed his desire to finish his career in Boston, as that did not happen and was told it would not happen until Nov. he felt slighted.   Management kept adding fuel to the fire with story leaks etc. Of course manny didn't help by not running out that ground ball against the no hitter.  Also manny takes a few games every year, but he is constantly up there in games played.  As far as shoving the traveling secretary, he was out of line no doubt, but it was a shove not an "attack" and we don't know the full story as to what was said other than a demand for tickets.  Also he doesn't have any history inside or outside baseball other than slapping Youkilis who is the biggest crybaby on the team.  If you have ever played sports with constant whiner and complainer you know what i mean.

Sox lost the most potent hitter in the line up who is a Yankee killer.  who hits in the clutch etc, and has the most post season HRs.   Bad move for the Sox as ortiz is 1 for 15 since Manny left and could still be hurt.  

He should honor his contract and play hard, but I can see his point in wanting a long term committment.  They could have agreed to rip up the option years and cut him loose or negotiated a new 4year 80m deal, he would have been happy and Boston would be in position to win another World series this year.
Manny won't be missed...after he gets a haircut, and pants that fit, no one will recognize him. Bay is more than happy to be in a Red Sox uniform, as he really dazzled the fans today with 4 hits. This is only the beginning!!
Sir:

I've previously blogged on this site in praise of Manny Ramirez and his sterling HOF cred. After that bizarre trade fiasco, I have listened to talk shows here in Boston, talked to friends locally, called everyone I know across the country. The verdict is unanimous: Manny being Manny used to be weird and unpredictable but fun in a goofy kind of way. Now, Manny has graduated to mean-spirited, hurtful, self-absorbed unprofessionalism and it is pathological. "Manny being Manny" has morphed into "Manny needs a Nanny." He also needs professional help. And by the way, according to all sources, Boston was held hostage and did the right thing. As Jason Bay blosoms and Nanny Boy continues his slow, inexorable decline, Boston fans will move on. Another World Series is in the offing.

PS: When Nanny Boy stopped playing while pretending to play, he - in effect- threw those games; thus helping his team loose on purpose. Where was the Commish during this Dog & Pony Show? Players have been permanently banned from this league for less. Think about it.

John Haberstroh (Boston)
I have to say I wish Joe Torre would go back to the American League.  I'm a D'backs fan in Phoenix, Arizona and I have to tell you with the Dodgers/D'backs game on Sun. taking TWO hours to complete four innings, the "rivalry" has lost all appeal for me.  I really didn't care who won the game at the end of four innings and frankly went out shopping.  Last night the D'backs' GAME lasted just under two hours--eight and one/half innings!  That's more like baseball.  Pitch fast, throw strikes!  I used to go to L.A. to watch my D'backs against the Dodgers--no longer.  Move the game foward Torre, or move back to the American League.
I have been a Red Sox fan for as long as I can remember, and I firmly believe that Manny did not get what he deserved in the long run.  I have to say I have enjoyed watching him play (when he played) and he has to be the best hitter going....but they say actions speak louder than words, and both his actions and his words in the past month or maybe longer, spoke volumes.  I agree with Mark from Modesto that he should be out of the game totally, and maybe THEN he would figure out that there is no "I" in TEAM. Now maybe the Red Sox can get something going!
Finally someone who makes sense out of nonsense! Mr. Pierce is so right on, that I could only add one further lawsuit. The Red Sox should sue Manny also on several fronts. Since MLB has no balls, the Courts ought to be used to straighten out wayward "spoil-sports" like Ramirez.
They ain't making heros like they used to.
There are teams not on the east coast????
Mark every word you said is true evil wins over good I guess.  PS Ifell sorry for Joe Torre when the Manny/Borris games begain   10days -2weeks  
All of a sudden , this Manny guy thinks he can do anything he wants to . I am so glad the Sox dumped him.He'll never go to the Yankees because he'll refuse to cut his hair and honor the dress code . He has gotten way too big for his britches.    
Correct me if I'm wrong. Schilling was the guy with the red sharpie and the redneck blowhard who was voted the most hated teammate in baseball. Manny carried the team into and through the World Series. That is why they give out Series MVP awards isn't it?
Manny got tired of carrying the Red Sox. Good luck seeing another World Series.
Manny has no honor. He is a spotlight seeking dweeb. He plays when he wants, mostly to the crowd. Despite his career he dishonors baseball and its traditions. I hope it all unravels for him. I guess it makes him a better player and more of a MAN RAM to beat up and intimidate a 64 year old man.

Honestly there are much better and more interesting stories than this dufus. I say enough MAN RAM and onto the real stories
I agree with Mark Pierce.  Depending on which behavior you think is worse (the traveling secretary debacle vs. the deliberate loafing) the commissioner should have either suspended Manny or banned Boras as the instigator of the contract option and trade "strategy".  The Commish did neither, so that leaves the free market to determine Manny's future.  This is not automatically a bad thing.  Without a doubt, these behavior problems dimish his value.  Here in 2008, he is a pretty solid 30 HR, 100 RBI guy.  But there are others who are younger, cheaper, and have less "baggage".  He's worth about as much as Gary Sheffield was at the same age.   This is a perfect opportunity for a little collusion.  The owners could easily decide that Manny and Boras are more trouble than they're worth.  All they have to do is pass on a 37 year-old guy with behavior issues.  As an added bonus, they could cite his "injuries" as a cause for concern.  This would prove that Boras is a moron for screwing up $40 million worth of club options that Manny could have pressured the team to pick up if he simply played up to his ability.   Besides, how can anyone guarantee that Manny won't be up to the same old tricks if he ends up on a team he doesn't like (or Boras finds a new path to payday?)  Maybe the solution is to let the free market take its course.  
This article appears to be a help wanted ad for a copy editor --and possibly a writer.
so you say no deals for a reliever, then praise the Yankees for picking up a reliever....
Jeff Kent will slap a knot on Manny's slap stick locks, he does not have any mental capacitiey
It has become another saga of presedental proportion that Manny could one day could be compared to the mistake The Red Sox made with Babe Ruth becoming a Yankee. This is just an insight to what perhaps will be in the near future provided the LA Dodgers win the 2008 world series.
While I am sick of hearing about Manny and Boras, I also think that their actions need to be given more attention..  Manny probably thinks he is clever to get out of his options.. Chances are this will benefit him financially. It certainly is benificial to Boras. However, I think that both their names and reputations have been tarnished much more than they predicted. Now everyone knows that Boras is not an honest person to do business with and will keep this in mind when dealing with him. The players will realize how dishonest Boras is and hopefully will not want him to represent them. As for Manny, no matter how he plays the rest of his career, this is what many people will remember him for. In the end, hopefully they will both get what they deserve.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):