About Sounding Off

Ted Robinson of NBCSports.com fires away on what’s making news in Major League Baseball, the National Football League and professional tennis.

Robinson called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has done play-by-play for the Minnesota Twins, San Francisco Giants, and New York Mets. Since 2000 Robinson has provided play-by-play for NBC Sports on the French Open and Wimbledon. He also previously served in that role at the U.S. Open for USA Network. Robinson is also the play-by-play voice of the San Francisco 49ers on KNBR.



Chicago fans take turn for the worse

Posted: Wednesday, May 14, 2008 2:13 PM

What has happened to major league baseball in Chicago? In the late 1970s, I went to college in Indiana, close enough to enjoy baseball in both Chicago ballparks. As a New Yorker, I was accustomed to tough press, fans that boo and the expectations created by the “Bronx Zoo” Yankees of that era.

So what did I find in Chicago? Mellow ball. Broadcaster Jack Brickhouse sounding like your favorite uncle selling mediocre Cubs players as budding stars. Ernie Banks wanting to play two and fans watching Cubs games from rooftops across the street from a half-full Wrigley Field. It was friendly, calm and probably too complacent. Winning was hoped for, not demanded.

On the South Side, White Sox owner Bill Veeck ran his victory lap with his team wearing softball uniforms, destroying disco records and Harry Caray and Jimmy Piersall serving as comic relief on broadcasts of the club’s games. It had more of an edge than Wrigley Field, but baseball at Comiskey Park was still serene compared to New York.

Thirty years later I watch as Chicago has morphed into a Midwest version of New York. There’s craziness as personified by Cubs manager Lou Piniella, whose volcanic on-field blowups were catalysts for a postseason run by the Cubs last season and White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen, whose mouth would have had many a manager fired.

 

It’s bitterness as boos now rain down on Alfonso Soriano, he of the numbers that don’t match his $136 million contract. The same accountability that has reigned in New York for three decades now exists in Chicago.

And it’s mean-spirited as a morning “gasbag” (the immortal description of many a sports-talk host coined by Al Michaels on HBO’s Costas Now) adopts a posture of “dim-witted machismo” (Joe Klein, TIME Magazine) in attacking Guillen and challenging anyone with a “problem” to a showdown on his turf. Pathetic and a reflection of Chicago sounding more like a big East Coast market.

 

When Dusty Baker took over managing the Cubs I shared with him my belief that he would love Chicago. How wrong I was!  Baker left four years later, stung by the negativity that he had rarely experienced in San Francisco but which was thriving in Chicago.

 

Chicago. It’s a hell of a town…unless you’re hitting .210, blowing saves or playing under .500 baseball.

 

FIVE MORE SWINGS

1. THEN THERE’S TAMPA…and St. Pete, Clearwater and every other town that comprises America’s second bay area. Eleven straight home wins and they Rays lead the American League East with a payroll nearly double their 2007 number -- all of $43 million. There are so many wonderful angles to ply here, but I look at two pitchers, both 24-year-old dynamic talents who were shunned by their original teams, Matt Garza (Twins) and Edwin Jackson (Dodgers). How important they have been to rounding out a promising young rotation.

2. THE SWINGS JINX…struck Reds shortstop Jeff Keppinger, just two days after the love thrown his way in this space. He fouled a pitch off his knee, fracturing his kneecap. The severity of the injury and length of his absence will soon be determined.

 

3. YOU CAN’T MAKE THIS UP…Armando Benitez lives! Back in the bigs, he’s one of the worst closers of this decade and a negative clubhouse influence. But Toronto took a chance that Benitez can still pitch some setup innings. The bet here is that he doesn’t survive the All-Star break.

 

4. SOMEONE ELSE IN THE SAME BOAT AS BENITEZ COULD BE...Jason Giambi. Here are the numbers: for a salary somewhere between 21 and 23 million, he has a batting average of .194 with decent power numbers (7 HR, 20 RBI) and walk total (22). The hope that Giambi could carry some of the load missing with A-Rod’s injury has died.

5. COULD HE POSSIBLY REACH 300 WINS? Don’t count out Randy Johnson. More hittable than ever (45 hits surrendered in 37 innings pitched this season), Johnson still won No. 287 last night. He looks healthy and he is playing for a strong team that can score runs. It’s unlikely Johnson could make it this year but if he gets close, does Arizona bring back a 45-year-old next season to chase a milestone?

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Excellent commentary.  I am a transplanted New Yorker living in suburban Chicagoland, and there is no question the press is as hard on the teams here as they were in New York.  (And the players don't always react well, either:  witness the 2004 Cubs' uprising when ex-broadcasters Steve Stone and Chip Carey dared to question their effort.)  Sometimes there's nothing they can do:  if the "gasbag" you refer to is the one who's been attacking Ozzie Guillen all week, he neither comes to White Sox games nor allows on-line commentary on his written pieces.

My four-year-old son and I went to Milwaukee to watch a game this weekend.  As has been the case with almost every other game I've seen outside of New York and Chicago (in cities such as Baltimore, San Francisco, and Cincinnati), no fistfights broke out among fans, I didn't have to cover my son's ears so he didn't hear expletives, and the fans genuinely enjoyed themselves.  I can only hope the malaise that affects the fans and media in NYC and the Second City stays there.
Sorry to hear your description of today's Cub fan!   I'm Brooklyn born & Dodger bred by Red Barber, etc.  Arrived in Chicago after Marines in '64.  Wrigley games were so inexpensive...park always 1/3 full, it seemed...even when Holtzman beat Kofax in Kofax's last regular season game!  Fans would applaud opponents good plays...always polite...certainly through my departing year of 1977.  (1969 season was tough to love the Mets) Moved to Minneapolis/St. Paul in 1985 and found the same type of fan.  Witnessed good-natured razing of players wives & friends during '87 World Series.  I was appaled in the '90's when I actually heard and witnessed Yankee fans at the "Shrine of Baseball" yelling "F..k You" at opposing players. Disgraceful!  Now Chicago, too!  I'm 72 yo and many times lately I am ashamed of my one-time wonderful Country!
Why should Chicago fans be held to a higher standard? I wonder how "mello" Yankee fans would be if they hadn't won for 100 years?
"Mellow Ball"  Nice term, but I can't tell if you are degrading Chicago for this approach in past years or yearning for its return.  As for me, a turn from the life-and-death struggle that baseball in Chicago has become would be very welcome.   As Harry said...."you can't beat fun at the ol' ballpark".  I wonder if Harry would find baseball in Chicago these days to be "fun".    Long live the spirit of Bill Veeck!
Why shouldn't we have a winner? You New York journalists are all alike-noses in the air for your teams and noses that droop for ours.  Why shouldn't we boo for a winning percentage of under .500 and so called hitters who can't hit their weight.  Trade 'em to New York!  We won't put up with them in Chicago anymore.
If your team hadn't won a World Series in 100 years, you might be a little negative, too.
Ted...can I call you Ted...here's the lowdown:

New York in the 70's - lousy fans, World Series ring
Chicago in the 70's - good fans, empty seats, no postseason

We in this city have always had expectations, but after 1985's Shuffle and the Jordan era, we expect way more from our baseball teams.  And we're willing to let our players and management know that.

Hey - we booed a lot thirty years ago, too!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):