ABOUT AT BAT

MSNBC.com baseball analyst Ted Robinson gives his take on the hits and misses by players, managers, umpires and owners in Major League Baseball.

Robinson has an extensive background in covering the sport. He called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has been the lead play-by-play announcer for the Minnesota Twins, the television and radio play-by-play voice of the San Francisco Giants, and a member of the New York Mets broadcast team.



MLB's Elite Eight heading into the season

Posted: Thursday, March 20, 2008 8:55 PM

Keeping with the theme of March Madness, I offer up my top eight teams coming out of spring training. 

No. 1 seeds:

 

RED SOX: The defending World Series winners didn’t blink when it appeared the Yankees would trade for Johan Santana. The Red Sox have held their farm system prizes and with Curt Schilling a question mark, young pitchers Jon Lester and Clay Buchholz will be important. Interesting move in the release of catcher Doug Mirabelli as management showed it is not fearful of disrupting “chemistry.”

 

YANKEES: The Bronx Bombers still have a ferocious lineup. Despite the pitching questions surrounding Mike Mussina and rookies Phil Hughes and Ian Kennedy, this team will score enough to overcome any problems on the mound. Joba Chamberlain starts in the bullpen, which indicates general manager Brian Cashman is firmly in charge and, further, that youth will finally be served in the Bronx.

 

TIGERS: One trade in the offseason put them in the top four. Acquired from the Marlins, Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis will help now while the young players traded for the two stars, talented as they are, are still not ready for prime time. Detroit’s lineup should rival that of the Yankees and the only question is the bullpen. If closer Todd Jones isn’t at his best, who is the backup? Plus, Fernando Rodney and Joel Zumaya open the season on the DL.

 

DIAMONDBACKS: Here’s the NL team that sneaks into a top seed. Arizona now has a premier pair of starters with Dan Haren joining Brandon Webb. The Diamondbacks’ rotation is deep enough to give them the luxury of hoping for, rather than needing, Randy Johnson. Solid at every position, they added supersub Chris Burke. Only question: can Brandon Lyon close?

 

The next three:


INDIANS: No changes were made to a team that played for the AL pennant last season. The Indians hit, field and run. They’ll find extra motivation to win for rotation ace C.C. Sabathia, who is in his money year with a contract expiring at season’s end. If Joe Borowski isn’t a sturdy closer, Cleveland already has his successor in Masahide Kobayashi.

 

METS: The addition of Johan Santana makes this team a contender. But there are more questions than the Mets care to hear: Can Pedro Martinez pitch a full season? Who plays left field with a fragile Moises Alou out again? Can Ryan Church handle a full year in right field? And can they erase the memory of last September?

 

CUBS: I see another step forward this season for Lou Piniella’s club. They added a major player in outfielder Kosuke Fukudome. It’s unrealistic to expect him to be the second coming of Ichiro, but if he’s a solid player then the Cubs’ lineup is cemented. Kerry Wood appears to be the closer and the Cubs have a deep rotation. The key for this team is can Carlos Zambrano, he of the new contract, be a staff leader?

 

At No. 8, a tie:

 

BRAVES: An underrated lineup will be bolstered by a full season from Mark Teixeira, another player motivated by free agency after the season. If Mark Kotsay’s back holds up, he is a solid replacement for Andruw Jones. Tom Glavine is back and if the Braves get any contribution from Mike Hampton, they will have fixed their rotation. Atlanta will score runs and should have solid starting pitching. If Rafael Soriano closes well, this is a playoff team.

 

ANGELS: A great offseason signing in Torii Hunter, but the Angels have a hole at shortstop, which they hope Erick Aybar can fill. Do Vlad Guerrero and Gary Matthews hold up for a full season? And if John Lackey’s injury is at all substantial, do the Angels have another No. 1 starter? Francisco Rodriguez is headed for free agency and the Angels hope his final act is clinching a playoff series.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Dear Mike
I think the Yankees had a there day in the Sun. I think the Orioles will have a winning season.
What about the dodgers! Expect great things this year from Dem-Bums!!!
This is the worst ranking I have seen for far. Not even close. How can the Yankees be so high with such a week set of staters? And the Cubs are a better team than the Angels? What? Even worse, the Angels are tied with the Braves? What? Is this guy a complete moron? The Angels are easily a top five team, even with some of the issues heading into the season. They are better than the Yankees. What is Ted Robinson smoking? Maybe he should head over to the college basketball dept, b/c he clearly either knows little about baseball or does not do his homework before writing nonsense like this. The Angels and Braves even. My god.
Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis will take the Tigers to the title - this year and beyond! The only question is if they are going to lose any games this year.. I'm thinking NO!
Better Question is who is the Final 4 - I'm going with Red Sox, Tigers, Braves, and Diamonbacks with Red Sox Repeating over the Braves in 5 (they can't sweep them all)
Where's the respect for the Phillies? Not saying the Mets and Braves are not quality teams, but last I checked the Phillies are the defending NL East champs, despite getting off to a horrible start last year and getting dinged over and over by injury.  Not to mention, the team has improved for 2008 getting Lidge as it's closer, which bolsters their starting rotation now that Brett Myers goes back there. They upgraded at 3rd base with Pedro Feliz and improved their bench with signings of Geoff Jenkins and So Taguchi. Not to mention Ryan Madsen is back healthy and in the bullpen. Are there question marks? Absolutely, but no more than the Mets or the Braves.
brewers
Don't even compare the Phillies to the Mets,Only reason Philly was champs was because Mets blew it.Anybody who plays in a Park where my 16yr old AAU team can hit it out can't be in the top 20 teams.Going to be a long year in Philly,you saw how good they did in the playoffs last year.None and Done


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):