ABOUT AT BAT

MSNBC.com baseball analyst Ted Robinson gives his take on the hits and misses by players, managers, umpires and owners in Major League Baseball.

Robinson has an extensive background in covering the sport. He called the play-by-play on NBC's Major League Baseball Game of the Week telecasts from 1986-89. Additionally, he has been the lead play-by-play announcer for the Minnesota Twins, the television and radio play-by-play voice of the San Francisco Giants, and a member of the New York Mets broadcast team.



A wish list for next season

Posted: Saturday, December 22, 2007 3:58 PM

Ten things I’d like to see in 2008:

 

10. Marvin Miller receives his due. I know well and greatly respect several members of the new Veterans Committee. But their thinking on this topic escapes me. And it is so out of touch with the vast majority of those around the game, so much so that even Fay Vincent believes Miller was wronged by not being elected to the Hall of Fame. In an emotion-charged op-ed piece for the New York Times, Vincent wrote that the decision to overlook Miller for election was “an act of ignorance and bias.”

 

9. The National League wins the All Star Game. Despite the influx of good young talent in the NL (just look at the shortstop position alone), it remains far behind the AL at the top. The imbalance only worsened when the Marlins traded Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis to Detroit. So, if the NL could somehow win the All-Star Game at least the league's champion would open the World Series at home.

 

8. Tom Glavine finish strong in Atlanta. In no way can I understand the treatment Glavine has received in New York since the season’s final day. In light of last week’s news, how many times do we have to be reminded that Glavine single-handedly caused the 2002 agreement that led to baseball’s first drug testing policy? Glavine has been exactly what Don Fehr has not: someone concerned about the greater good of the game. I want him to end his Hall-of- Fame career on a high note.

 

7. Baseball polices its clubhouses. The Mitchell Report fully exposed one big problem: entourages aren’t limited to players. Clubhouse managers hire assistants for low wages with little or no qualifications. No longer can baseball afford to be infected by a Kirk Radomski. All clubhouse employees should be thoroughly checked. And EVERY clubhouse employee, including the manager, should be paid TOTALLY by teams. No more tips or dues from players. Baseball must clearly state and delineate that clubhouses belong to the teams, not the players.

 

6. The Tampa Bay litmus test. How many years running will we hear of the young talent stockpile in Tampa Bay? We are told how many top-rated prospects are flooding out of their system into the bigs. At year’s end, they have the same disappointing result. Ten years of play, 10 years of 90-plus losses. I hope to see Tampa Bay finally achieve any semblance of success so we can determine without doubt if it is a major- league market.

 

5. Another great finish. Seven NL teams were still alive for the playoffs on the final Friday. Yes, the AL is the stronger league, but I wouldn’t trade the last week of the NL season for anything. Tony Gwynn Jr. spoiling the Padres is one of the great baseball stories for all times. How can we forget the “perfect storm” of joy in Philadelphia and utter disgust in New York on the last Sunday of the season?

 

4. Cooperation from Major League Baseball Players Association. Reading the union’s thoughts this week, as articulated in their New York Times column, leads me to worry that the Mitchell Report aftermath will find the union resuming antagonistic relations with Major League Baseball. And who wins in that scenario? Will union leadership recognize and acknowledge John Marzano’s thoughts as repeated in my last blog? Will union leadership ensure the protection of honest players? Or will they revert to the decades-old position of friction with management that led to disastrous work stoppages? Will everyone breathe deeply and understand that the meteoric growth of baseball revenues coincides with 13 uninterrupted seasons? Just a hope they will.

 

3. Better times in San Francisco. You think the Mitchell Report thrilled the Giants? No team was treated worse as the report displayed to the world their enabling of Barry Bonds. But I emphasize that the same ownership not only saved baseball in San Francisco, but also created a thriving franchise in a magnificent ballpark. As someone employed by the Giants for nine years of that era, I know how much joy exists within the walls of 24 Willie Mays Plaza that Bonds is gone. Their farm system is bereft of position players, a victim of the win-today mindset necessitated by the presence of Bonds as well as some poor drafting. Thus, there will be short-term pain as the team stumbles in a NL West filled with tons of young talent. Yet, I hope that this franchise looks not for quick fixes but follows a blueprint that allows its baseball department to match its wildly successful business operation.

 

2. More trades. The most heartening development of this offseason has been the return of the player-for-player deal. Fans relate, especially in this fantasy era. And anything that generates baseball talk while lessening the presence of dollar signs is a positive.

 

1. A steroid-free year. A dream, I admit, with the Barry Bonds trial now joined by the Roger Clemens saga. But I sense steroid fatigue amongst the fandom. I feel it, and I am friends of and friendly with many names in the Mitchell Report. It hit close to home and I am guilty as charged of subscribing to the “move forward” theory. But I fear there are still hunters who want more names. And I fear that MLB will counter prevailing wisdom and punish offenders outed in the Mitchell Report.  

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Good piece, Ted. At least six of your 10 items actually had to do with the sport of baseball as it's played on the field, as opposed to all the other stuff. That's significantly above the national media average. And just for fun, I'll add a few more to your 10 ...

11. If you're going give Marvin Miller his due, you can't forget his counterpart, Curt Flood. By your logic, doesn't he belong on the Hall, too? Now personally, I don't see either one of them in the HOF. I mean, largely thanks to them, we now have players making more money in a month than I ever made in five years, we had a World Series cancelled, and we have such intense competition for all those loose millions that players will do *anything* to grab what they see as their due. I'm not going so far as to say that the Steroid Era is Marvin Miller's fault, but indirectly his "contributiouns" to the game set the wheels in motion for it.

12. More 20-game winners. I'm still mystified as to why starting pitchers 30 years ago didn't consider it a full year if they didn't work 250-plus innings, but today that's considered overwork. But what I'm really saying, I guess, is that I wish baseball would let the pendulum swing back from the home run crazed excesses that began with McGuire-Sosa, and more toward good pitching. I don't know if it was Yogi who said that "good pitching always beats good hitting, and vice versa", but if it wasn't, it should have been. To my way of thinking, a shutout is just as dramatic and just as exciting as a walk-off homer.

13. Less media attention on the Yankees. I'd think you guys would be embarrassed to death to write yet another story headlined "Will the Yankees Make the Playoffs?"

14. I'd like to see television come up with some new twists on how the sport is presented over the air. I have no idea what, exactly, but there are some really creative people at ESPN and Fox. Let them flex their creative muscles a bit. Baseball is a sport of almost infinite subtlties ... let us see them in a way that we haven't before.

15. For god's sake, do something about the number of grotesquely broken bats that send jagged pieces of wood flying out onto the field like shrapnel. It's only a matter of time before a pitcher or third baseman or base coach gets one of these daggers in the face or even through the heart. I do NOT mean switching to aluminum ... but surely the might of American technology can produce non-breaking wood bats.

16. Instant replay. The NFL and NBA have paved the way. Now follow their lead, but do them one better.

17. Have a *real* World Series. Everyone saw how well the World Baseball Classic went over ... move it after the Major League World Series and play for the championship of the entire world. What a spectacle that would be! I'm certain it would rival the Super Bowl or the Olympics for world-wide interest. I don't understand why Bud and the owners are against this idea. Is MLB so afraid they'd lose to Cuba or Japan or the Dominican, and threaten their supposed superiority? Haha, I've got news for them ...

it's greta to have a wish list for 2008. BUT do to the Mitchell report I think we are in for a year of rumors, alagations and uproar, along with paydays for a single man that could feed a small city. Lets add to the wish list GOOD OLD AMERICAN BASEBALL. Play ball
Quick, MSNBC or ESPN, hire John Provine.  He obviously can think, and he shows above that he can express those thoughts well in the written word...not a common thing.
There is 1 thing to add to yr wish list-to be able to read a baseball blog w/o having to wade through so much cursing, trash-talk & utter babble that makes no sense & has nothing to do with the game itself-let alone the game that is being discussed or was just played at the the time.  It would be so nice to just discuss baseball with people who love the game & want to talk to others about HOF'ers to be or those who just got elected or who should/shouldn't be elected etc.  Not get cursed out because you disagree with someone or don't like their team like so many of these blog sites do.  It's disgraceful & so my wish is for a decent blog site that is respectful to all serious baseball bloggers & blogettes as the case may be.  Thanx for listening.  Great article.
Marvin Miller is a weasel along with Fehr. Neither of them should ever be allowed near the HOF without paying an admission fee.
Don't the writers elect the members of the HOF?  How could these guys NOT see the impact that Marvin Miller has made on the game.  For the cival rights of athletes in general, he and Curt Flood probably rank just behind Jackie Robinson and Larry Dobe.
An important thing missing from your list is the unbalanced media attention that the NY teams, Boston, and the LA teams receive. I for one, am tired of seeing these teams allllllll the time on national television. I would like to see the networks cover all of MLB with a little more balance. But I know the folks at Budweiser and Chevrolet, etc. will have none of that...the real powers that be chase The Almighty Dollar and don't really care about the fans of the game as a whole.
It amazes me that the "self-annointed" have set rules that sports figures cannot use a perfectly legal substance, namely, steroids.  Steroids are commonly and frequently given to patients for breathing problems, muscle problems, etc., even to my 6 year old grandson.  The only person continued and prolonged steroid use affects is the USER.  Kind of like the non-smokers telling me when and where I can smoke.  Give me a break!


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):